Brothers who have served as Worshipful Master and have passed the Oriental Chair to those whom have come after them are known as Past Masters. These Brothers served with honor and prestige to ensure the mission and vision of Silver Square Lodge No. 43 was always upheld to the highest standards. The following are those Brothers:
- Earl H. Underwood
- Jame E. Parker
- Lee Roy Allen
- Ahmad T. Mathis
- Robert F. Mathis
- Joe N. Evans
- Timothy D. Wilson (Demitted in from Tyre Lodge No. 60)